Cloud sync or backup: what is the difference?
Sync keeps files identical, while a backup keeps earlier states; you need both for good protection.
Sync keeps files identical across several devices, even when you delete or change something. A backup keeps a separate copy with earlier versions, so you can go back after a mistake or an attack. For good protection you use both.
Who is it for: Individuals and families who use cloud storage and want to know whether their files are also protected against loss.
What is sync?
Syncing means that a folder has the same contents on several devices and in the cloud at all times. If you add a file on your laptop, it appears on your phone. If you delete it, it disappears from your phone too. The service does exactly what you ask, even when that is a mistake.
That is why sync is first and foremost a convenience: you work with the same files everywhere. It is not intended to protect you against your own mistakes, although many services have a recycle bin or limited version history that partly covers this.
What is a backup?
A backup is a separate copy of your data at a different point in time, kept in a place that does not automatically follow what you do on your device. A good backup keeps several restore points, for example from yesterday, last week and last month. That way you can go back to a state from before the problem.
The distinction comes down to one question: what happens if I delete something or files get damaged? With sync, the mistake spreads. With a backup, the old version remains available, as long as the retention period has not expired.
Why ransomware makes this difference important
Ransomware is malicious software that encrypts your files and demands a ransom for recovery. On a computer with synced folders, such an attack can pass the encrypted files on to the cloud, making the cloud copy unusable as well. Some services offer version history that lets you restore earlier versions, but the period and the ease of doing so differ per provider and subscription.
A backup that cannot be changed directly by your device offers a better chance of recovery. Ask a provider whether earlier versions are retained, for how long, and whether they are also protected against unwanted changes from your account.
When do you choose which?
Sync suits files you work on daily and need on several devices. A backup suits everything you do not want to lose, such as photos, paperwork and proof documents. In practice you use both, on different layers.
- Use sync for working folders, current documents and shared files.
- Use a backup for photos, paperwork and anything you cannot recreate.
- Keep at least one copy in a separate place that does not automatically follow your devices.
- Check regularly that you can really restore a file.
Sync and backup side by side
| Situation | Sync | Backup |
|---|---|---|
| You delete a file by accident | Usually disappears everywhere, unless there is a recycle bin | Earlier version remains available |
| A file gets damaged | The damaged version is copied | You can restore an earlier version |
| Ransomware encrypts files | Encrypted files may sync along | Recovery possible from an earlier restore point |
| You lose your device | Files are still in the cloud | Files are still in the backup |
| You want the same files everywhere | This is what it is designed for | Not the purpose of a backup |
Who is it not ideal for?
- If you only sync and think that is enough: add a backup for everything you do not want to lose.
- If you want a backup without managing anything: choose a service with automatic backup and check the version history.
- If you are working with a very limited budget: an external drive with a periodic copy is a simple start, provided you store it separately.
Frequently asked questions
Is a recycle bin in the cloud the same as a backup?
No. A recycle bin usually keeps deleted files temporarily, and only if you delete them. A backup also keeps earlier versions and protects against more kinds of problems.
Can a cloud provider be my backup?
Yes, if the service explicitly offers backup with version history and you know how long versions are kept. A service that only syncs is not a backup.
How often should a backup run?
That depends on how often your files change. For photos, weekly is sometimes enough; for documents you work on daily, more often is better. Set it according to what you could afford to lose.
