Comparing privacy-friendly cloud storage: the criteria
You judge privacy-friendly cloud storage on key management, metadata, location, tracking and transparency, not on a privacy promise in an advert.
You judge privacy-friendly cloud storage on five points: who manages the keys, how metadata is handled, where data is stored and who can access it, what tracking the service uses, and how transparent the provider is. For each point, look for evidence in documentation, audits and the data processing agreement.
Who is it for: Individuals and small businesses looking for cloud storage with attention to privacy who want to know what to compare on.
What makes cloud storage privacy-friendly?
There is no quality mark that applies to all services, and the word privacy is used broadly in marketing. Privacy-friendly is therefore not a property you read on the packaging, but the outcome of a number of concrete choices that you can check.
Below are five criteria. They are meant to compare providers with each other without relying on promises alone. For each criterion, a good answer is specific, in writing and verifiable.
Key management and metadata
The most important criterion is who manages the encryption key. If the provider holds the key, the provider can read your files. With user-managed keys, that is not the case. Also check whether encryption is on by default, applies to all file types and all plans, and what happens if you lose your password.
Metadata is data about your files, such as names, folder structure, sizes, timestamps and who you share with. It can reveal a lot, even if the content is encrypted. Ask whether metadata is also encrypted or stored readably at the provider, and how long log files are kept.
Location, tracking and transparency
Location is about more than the country of the data centre. It also concerns who operates the service, who owns the company and which laws apply to it. European does not automatically mean private: location, ownership and management are three different things. So also read the information about subcontractors.
Tracking looks at what the service itself measures. Does the website or app use advertising or analytics trackers, and is usage data shared with third parties? A privacy statement that clearly says what does not happen is more valuable than one that only lists what is allowed.
Transparency means that the provider itself shows how it works. Think of security documentation, a transparency report on requests from authorities and independent audit reports.
- Security documentation that explains the encryption technically
- A data processing agreement that states which data is processed, by whom and for what purpose
- A recent audit report from an independent party, stating its scope
- A list of sub-processors and the country where they are established
How do you apply this in practice?
Make a simple score per criterion and note where you found the evidence. A criterion for which you can find nothing counts as unknown, not as good. Also test the service with a trial account before you move all your files.
- Decide what you want to protect: only the content, or also who you are and who you share with.
- For each criterion, look for the evidence in the provider’s documentation.
- Read the privacy statement and the data processing agreement on the points in the table.
- Compare the outcomes and weigh them against convenience and functionality.
The five criteria at a glance
| Criterion | What do you check | Why it counts |
|---|---|---|
| Key management | Who holds the key, on by default or not, for which files and plans | Determines whether the provider can read your content |
| Metadata | Are file names, structure and sharing details encrypted, and how long are logs kept | Metadata reveals behaviour and contacts, even without content |
| Location and management | Data location, company owner, management, support access and sub-processors | Determines which parties and legal systems can gain access |
| Tracking | Analytics and advertising trackers in site and app, sharing with third parties | Limits how much the service knows about your use |
| Transparency | Documentation, audits, transparency report, data processing agreement | Makes claims verifiable |
Who is it not ideal for?
- Users who mainly need features such as collaborative editing and smart search: strong privacy measures sometimes limit these.
- Organisations with legal requirements for retention and access: have the choice reviewed legally before you decide.
- People who do not want to spend time on documentation: the choice then stays based on promises, and that is less reliable.
Frequently asked questions
Is free storage less privacy-friendly?
Not necessarily, but check how the provider funds its service. If advertising or data use is part of the revenue model, read carefully what happens with your data.
Does a privacy label from the provider itself count as evidence?
It is a starting point. Independent audits and technical documentation that you can read yourself carry more weight.
Should I encrypt everything or only sensitive files?
That depends on your threat model and convenience. Many people choose a separate encrypted folder for sensitive documents and use the standard options for the rest.
