Comparing cloud storage for small businesses: criteria
Criteria and check questions for comparing cloud storage for files and collaboration in a small business.
Compare cloud storage for a small business on management of users and permissions, sharing with external parties, version history, location of data, backup options and how you get your files back when you leave. Cost differences follow from the number of users and storage.
Who is it for: Small businesses and freelancers with a few to a few dozen employees who want to share and store files online.
Which cloud do we mean?
This is about cloud for files and collaboration: storing, sharing and synchronising documents between devices. It is not about infrastructure such as servers or object storage for your own product; other criteria apply there, which are covered in the guides for start-ups.
For a business, the requirements are higher than for private use. Several people work on the same files, employees come and go, and there are customers whose data you protect.
Which criteria matter most?
List the criteria before you look at providers. That way you avoid a nice feature outweighing a requirement you did not actually have.
- User management: can you create and disable accounts centrally and give groups permissions? Is single sign-on (SSO) possible if you use it?
- Sharing: can you secure links with a password or end date, and can you see who has shared what?
- Versions and recovery: how long are earlier versions and deleted files kept?
- Location and legal framework: where is the data and who manages it? Have this checked legally for personal data.
- Security: is MFA available and can you enforce it for all employees?
- Backup: is there a separate copy, or is synchronisation all you have?
How are the costs built up?
Without amounts, you can still compare the structure. A provider usually charges per user, per amount of storage or a combination. An example calculation: number of users times the rate per user, plus extra storage in GB times the rate per GB. Check whether features such as version history, admin rights and extra storage are included in your subscription or charged separately.
What do you check during a trial period?
Let a few colleagues work with real files for a week. Note how difficult it is to set permissions correctly, how synchronisation copes with large files and what happens when two people edit at the same time. Also test restoring a deleted file and exporting a folder.
Comparison criteria for cloud storage
| Criterion | Check question | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| User management | Can I manage accounts and groups centrally? | Employees come and go |
| Sharing with external parties | Can I restrict and revoke links? | Prevents data circulating uncontrolled |
| Versions and recovery | How far back in time can I go? | Protection against mistakes and ransomware |
| Location | Where is the data and who manages it? | Relevant for the GDPR |
| Exit | How do I get everything out in a usable format? | Prevents you being locked in |
| Costs | Per user, per GB or both? | Determines how the bill grows |
Who is this less suitable for?
- Businesses with very large files such as video: watch for per-file limits and upload speed; a NAS or object storage may be a better fit.
- Organisations with strict requirements on location or self-management: a private solution may be more suitable.
- People who want to use cloud storage as their only backup: synchronisation is not a backup.
Frequently asked questions
Is free cloud storage suitable for a business?
Usually not. It often lacks user management, agreements on data processing and support. Check the terms per provider.
What is the difference with a NAS?
A NAS is your own storage device at the office. Cloud storage is held by a provider. The trade-off is about management, accessibility and costs.
Do I need a data processing agreement?
For personal data of customers or employees, usually yes. Have legal advice confirm what applies to your situation.
