Comparing Dutch and European cloud storage: what to look for
With Dutch or European cloud storage it comes down to three questions: where is the company based, where is the data and who owns it.
With Dutch or European cloud storage, country of establishment, data location and ownership are three different things. A European data centre does not automatically mean a service is private. Also check who manages it, who provides support and which subcontractors have access.
Who is it for: Individuals and small businesses who deliberately look for Dutch or European cloud storage and want to know what that label means.
What do we mean by Dutch or European?
The label European is used in different ways. To compare providers fairly, you can split it into three questions. They are separate properties, and a provider can score on one and not on another.
- Country of establishment: where is the company legally established and which law does it fall under?
- Data location: in which country or region are the servers on which your files are stored?
- Ownership and management: who is the ultimate owner of the company, and who manages the systems and has access?
What does the GDPR cover, and what does it not?
The GDPR (General Data Protection Regulation) sets rules for the processing of personal data of people in the European Union. A provider established in the EU must comply with those rules, even if the data is stored elsewhere. When data goes to countries outside the EU, additional conditions apply.
The GDPR says nothing about the technology. A service can follow the GDPR and still keep the keys itself, so that staff can technically access your content. Whether foreign legislation such as the American CLOUD Act can apply depends on the situation; have it assessed legally. This article gives no opinion on that.
A European data location therefore does not resolve every concern. If a parent company is outside Europe, or management and support take place from another country, access may still lie outside Europe.
What do you look for in practice?
Use the following checks when you compare two or more providers. Look for the answers in the privacy statement, the data processing agreement and the security documentation, and not only on the homepage.
- Look up where the company is established and who the owner is, including parent companies.
- Check in which countries the data is stored, including for backups and copies.
- See who manages the systems and from which country support staff can access them.
- Read the list of sub-processors and where they are established.
- Ask who manages the encryption key; this weighs more heavily than the country.
- Look for a recent independent audit report and note which parts it covers.
Is Dutch better than European?
Not by definition. A Dutch provider is familiar to those who value Dutch-language support and Dutch law, but a provider from another EU country can be just as good technically and organisationally, or better. Assess on the three questions above and on the technical measures, not only on the flag.
Three things that are often mixed up
| Term | Question to the provider | What it does not prove |
|---|---|---|
| Country of establishment | Where is the company established and who is the owner? | That the data is also there or that management takes place there |
| Data location | In which countries are storage and backups located? | That only European parties can access it |
| Management and support | Who manages the systems and from which country? | That the content is unreadable to administrators |
| Key management | Who holds the encryption key? | That the service complies with all legislation |
Who is it not ideal for?
- Anyone who mainly wants a good service without interest in the background: functionality and convenience may then weigh more heavily than origin.
- Anyone who thinks a European provider is automatically private: your own encryption is then a better choice.
- Businesses with specific sector rules: have the choice assessed legally, because what complies depends on the situation.
Frequently asked questions
Can a Dutch service still store data outside Europe?
Yes, for example for backups or via a subcontractor. The data processing agreement and the list of sub-processors give clarity on this.
Do I need to sign a data processing agreement as an individual?
As an individual usually not; it is mainly intended for organisations that process other people's personal data. For a small business it is relevant.
Does a certificate for European storage count?
As evidence, yes, provided you can see who issued it, what it covers and how current it is. A logo without explanation is not evidence.
