Nextcloud or NAS software: hosting your own files
Self-hosting is possible with built-in NAS software or open-source software such as Nextcloud; the choice is about maintenance, flexibility and responsibility.
Built-in NAS software is easier to start with and is maintained by the manufacturer. Open-source software such as Nextcloud offers more freedom and features, but you maintain the installation, updates and security. Both call for a backup and regular attention.
Who is it for: Users who want to host their own files and are choosing between built-in NAS features and open-source software.
What are the two routes?
The first route uses the features the manufacturer offers on your NAS: file sharing, synchronisation, photos and backup. The second route involves installing open-source software yourself, such as Nextcloud, on your NAS or on a separate server. Open source means the source code is public and the software is developed by a community and companies.
Nextcloud offers file synchronisation, sharing and a web interface, and can be extended with additional apps. What exactly is available depends on the version and the apps chosen.
What changes in management and updates?
With built-in software, the manufacturer supplies updates for the system and the apps, as long as the model is supported. You do have to install them and check how long your model receives updates.
With self-hosted software, you are responsible for the entire chain: operating system, web server, database, the application and the associated certificates. That gives freedom, but every layer needs updates and attention. A missed update can leave a vulnerability.
How do you choose?
Ask yourself a few questions before you start:
- How much time and knowledge do I have to maintain this?
- Do I want features that the built-in software doesn’t offer?
- What happens to my data if the software or the model is no longer supported?
- Can I easily move the data if I want to switch later?
What applies to both routes?
Both share the same basic rules: RAID is not a backup, remote access increases the risk, and a single location is vulnerable. So make an encrypted offsite copy and limit access from outside, preferably via a VPN.
Open source also doesn’t automatically mean more or less secure. The source code can be viewed by many, but the security of your installation depends on how you set it up and maintain it. Keep up with the project’s documentation and check whether there is an active community that publishes security notices.
Built-in or self-installed
| Aspect | Built-in NAS software | Self-hosted open source |
|---|---|---|
| Start | Simple, often ready to use | More installation and configuration |
| Updates | Via the manufacturer, as long as the model is supported | You manage all components |
| Features | Limited to what the manufacturer offers | Extendable with additional apps |
| Responsibility | Shared with the manufacturer for the system | Largely with you |
| Switching | Depends on export options | Often more flexible, but takes work |
Who is it less suited for?
- People who have no time for updates: choose built-in software or a managed service.
- People who only need simple file sharing: extra software then mainly adds maintenance.
- People who share sensitive data and have no security knowledge: have an expert check the set-up.
Frequently asked questions
Can I run Nextcloud on any NAS?
That depends on the model, the available container support and the processing power. Check the software's requirements and your NAS's capabilities.
What is a container?
A container is an isolated environment in which a program runs with its components. Docker is a well-known way of using containers.
How often should I install updates?
That depends on the project. Read the security update announcements and schedule a fixed moment to check.
What if the project stops?
Keep your data in standard formats and make a backup, so you can switch.
