Online or offline backup: pros and cons
Online backup (cloud) versus offline backup (drive or NAS): what suits you and why you often want both.
An online backup sits with a provider on the internet, an offline backup sits on a drive or device that you manage yourself. Online is automatic and protects against fire or theft at home. Offline is quick to restore and works without internet. For important data, a combination is sensible.
Who is it for: Individuals and small businesses who want to choose between the cloud and their own drive.
What do we mean by online and offline?
An online backup is sent over the internet to a provider’s servers. An offline backup sits on an external drive, USB stick or NAS that you manage yourself. The term offline here mainly means: under your own control and not reachable via the internet. A NAS that is permanently connected to the network is therefore less offline than a drive in a drawer.
Advantages of an online backup
- The copy is in a different location, so fire, burglary or water damage at home does not affect it.
- It runs automatically in the background, without you having to connect anything.
- Many services keep several versions, so you can also go back after a mistake.
Disadvantages of an online backup
- The first backup and a full restore can take days on a slow internet connection.
- You depend on the provider, its terms and your subscription.
- Privacy: look at where the data is and who manages the keys.
Advantages and disadvantages of an offline backup
A drive is quick to restore and costs no subscription. The drawback is that you have to take care of connecting, checking and replacing it yourself. If the drive sits next to your computer, it is also gone in a fire or burglary. A drive that stays permanently connected can moreover be encrypted by ransomware.
What do you choose?
Combine. A local copy provides quick recovery, an online copy protection against disasters. That brings you close to the 3-2-1 rule.
Online and offline backup side by side
| Topic | Online | Offline |
|---|---|---|
| Location | With a provider, outside your home | With you, unless you keep the drive elsewhere |
| Automatic | Usually yes | Only if you set it up |
| Recovery speed | Depends on your internet | Usually fast |
| Costs | Usually a subscription | One-off purchase, sometimes replacement |
| Risk | Depends on provider and terms | Can break, get lost or burn along with everything else |
Who is this less suitable for?
- Anyone who only synchronises a cloud folder and calls that a backup: that is not an independent copy.
Frequently asked questions
Is an online backup safe?
That depends on the provider and on your settings. Pay attention to encryption, two-step verification and who manages the keys.
Should I use both?
For important data that is sensible: one fast local copy and one copy elsewhere.
Is a NAS an offline backup?
A NAS is a local copy, but it is connected to your network. So also keep a copy somewhere else.
