Private AI or public AI: consequences for data and infrastructure
Public AI service or private AI in your own environment: what does it mean for data, control, costs and management?
With a public AI service, a provider processes your input on its infrastructure; that is quick and easy but requires agreements about data. With private AI the model runs in your own or a shielded environment, which gives more control but requires more management. Choose based on the sensitivity of the data, regulations and available knowledge.
Who is it for: Organisations that want to use AI with business or personal data and are weighing up where the model runs.
What do we mean by public and private?
You use a public AI service through the provider’s website or API. Your input is processed on its systems. With private AI, a model runs in an environment that you or a partner manage: on your own hardware, in your own cloud environment or at a provider with shielded capacity for you alone.
What shifts for your data?
With public use you need to know what the provider does with your input: store it, log it, use it for training? Read the terms and choose settings that switch off use for training if that is possible. With private AI the data stays within your environment, but you are then also responsible for security, access and retention periods.
Advantages and disadvantages
- Public: quick to start, no hardware management, steadily improving models; less control over what happens to data.
- Private: more control, traceable, customisable; requires hardware, knowledge, maintenance and your own security.
- A mix is possible: sensitive tasks private, general tasks public.
What to look for
- Sensitivity of data: personal data, trade secrets, customer data.
- Regulation, such as the GDPR and the European AI Act, where applicable.
- Contracts and data processing agreements with providers.
- Location of processing and where backups and logs end up.
- Knowledge and capacity to manage your own environment.
Choosing step by step
Start by classifying your data. Use a public service with good agreements for non-sensitive tasks and an environment where you keep control yourself for sensitive tasks. Record this in a policy for employees, so that nobody accidentally pastes sensitive data into a public service.
Public and private AI compared
| Topic | Public AI | Private AI |
|---|---|---|
| Start | Immediate | Setting up takes time |
| Data control | Through agreements with the provider | Within your own environment |
| Management | With the provider | With you or your partner |
| Customisation | Limited to what the service allows | Plenty of freedom |
| Costs | Per use | Higher fixed costs for hardware or capacity |
Who is it not ideal for?
- Those who only process non-sensitive, public information: a public service is usually sufficient then.
Frequently asked questions
Is private AI automatically safer?
Not automatically. You keep more control, but you also have to secure, update and monitor it yourself.
Does a public provider use my data for training?
That differs per provider and plan. Read the terms and settings.
What do I need to arrange with employees?
A clear policy on which data may and may not go into AI services.
