Which NAS to buy? Selection criteria without brand preference
Choose a NAS based on drive bays, performance, network, software and updates, with a checklist to compare models.
Choose a NAS based on what you want to do with it: the number of drive bays, the processor and memory, the network speed, the software and how long the manufacturer provides updates. First determine your storage needs and whether you want to stream media or synchronise files, then compare models on these criteria.
Who is it for: Home users and small businesses who want to buy a NAS and are not looking for brand advice, but for criteria.
Start with how you will use it
Write down what the NAS has to do: share files, back up several computers, store photos, stream films or run a small server. A simple storage need requires less than a NAS that converts several videos at once.
Number of drive bays and storage
More drive bays give more space and more options for failure protection with RAID. Allow for growth: add up your current data, add growth and do not forget the space needed for RAID. Check whether the model supports drives of the size you want and see whether the manufacturer publishes a list of compatible drives.
Performance
For simple file storage, a modest processor is enough. If you rely heavily on streaming with video conversion, virtual machines or many users, a more powerful processor and more memory are important.
Network and expansion
- A gigabit connection is enough for a lot of home use; a faster network pays off with large files and several users.
- Check whether your router and cabling can handle the speed.
- See whether you can add or replace drives later.
- Look at the connection for an uninterruptible power supply.
Software and updates
A NAS is a computer on your network, so updates are important. Look at how long the manufacturer provides security updates, how the apps for synchronisation and backup work and whether you can reach the NAS securely from outside your home.
Power, noise and costs
A NAS often runs around the clock. Look at the consumption when idle and in use, and at the noise if it will be in the living room. Also count the drives: they are often a large part of the total costs.
Do not forget the backup
A NAS with RAID protects against the failure of a drive. Against fire, ransomware or deletion it offers little protection on its own, although snapshots can help. Plan a copy in another place, for example in the cloud or on a drive elsewhere.
Checklist for comparing NAS models
| Criterion | Question | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Drive bays | How many drives fit in? | Determines space and RAID options |
| Processor and memory | Enough for your use? | Affects speed and features |
| Network | Which connection and speed? | Limits the transfer speed |
| Software | Which apps, how long are updates provided? | Determines convenience and security |
| Consumption and noise | How much power and noise? | It is often on day and night |
| Backup options | Can it copy to the cloud or a drive? | For a copy off-site |
Who is this less suitable for?
- Anyone with few files who does not want to manage anything: a cloud service is then simpler.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need RAID?
RAID protects against the failure of a drive but is not a backup. It is useful if the NAS has to be available continuously.
Can I install my own drive?
Usually yes, but check the manufacturer's compatibility list.
How long does a NAS last?
That depends on the model and the updates. Look at the support period.
