Cloud or local storage: what suits your situation?
A sober comparison of storage in the cloud and storage on your own equipment, with criteria to help you make your own choice.
Cloud storage keeps your files with a provider and is reachable from anywhere. Local storage sits on equipment you manage yourself. Which suits you depends on access, management effort, recovery needs and the control you want over your data.
Who is it for: For individuals and small organisations who want to know whether their files are better placed with a provider or on their own equipment.
What is the difference between cloud and local storage?
With local storage, your files are on a drive or system that you hold yourself, such as a computer, an external drive or a NAS. With cloud storage, they are on a provider’s servers that you reach via the internet.
It is therefore a question of who owns and manages the equipment. That determines who takes care of maintenance, power, replacement of faulty components and security.
What to look for with cloud storage
Cloud storage is reachable from multiple devices and places, and sharing with others is usually simple. You do not have to manage hardware, and capacity can often be expanded.
There are trade-offs, though. You depend on an internet connection and on the provider’s terms. You need to find out where the data is, who manages the keys and what happens if you stop the subscription.
What to look for with local storage
Local storage gives you direct control and fast access within your own network, even without internet. You decide where the equipment is and who can access it.
You are responsible for maintenance and recovery yourself. A drive can fail, equipment can be stolen or damaged by fire or water. Without a copy in another place, you can lose data.
How do you choose?
It is rarely a matter of only one or the other. A commonly used approach is to work locally and keep a copy off-site.
- If you need access from multiple places and devices, cloud weighs more heavily.
- If you want full control or work with very large files on a fast local network, local weighs more heavily.
- If you have little time for management, a provider takes that part over.
- For recovery after loss, a copy in a second location helps, in whatever form.
Cloud and local compared
| Criterion | Cloud storage | Local storage |
|---|---|---|
| Access | Via the internet, from multiple places | Direct in your own network; from outside only with extra set-up |
| Management | By the provider, partly by you | Entirely by you or your administrator |
| Control over data | Depends on terms and key management | High, provided you set it up well |
| Recovery after loss | Depends on the service; check whether restorable versions exist | Only with your own copy in another place |
| Dependence | On provider and connection | On your own equipment and maintenance |
Who is it not ideal for?
- Cloud only is less suitable if you regularly work without a reliable connection or edit very large files locally.
- Local only is less suitable if you work from multiple places or cannot keep a copy outside your location.
- Self-managed storage is less suitable if you have nobody to keep up with updates and drive replacement.
Frequently asked questions
Is cloud syncing the same as a backup?
No. Syncing mirrors changes, including deletions. A backup keeps earlier versions that you can restore. Check what your service offers.
Can I combine both?
Yes, that is common: work locally and keep an encrypted copy in the cloud, or the other way round. Ask the service who manages the key.
What if my internet connection goes down?
With local storage you can carry on working. Many cloud services offer an offline mode for selected files; check how that works and how changes are merged afterwards.
