Cloud storage, NAS and private cloud compared side by side
Three forms of storage compared on management, cost structure, control and scalability.
Cloud storage is the simplest and needs no hardware of your own, a NAS gives you your own storage with more control and management, and a private cloud is intended for organisations that want scale and control of their own. Your choice depends on how much you want to manage yourself and how much control you need.
Who is it for: Anyone torn between cloud storage, a NAS and a private cloud, at home or at work.
What is the main difference?
The difference lies mainly in who takes care of the hardware and the management. With cloud storage the provider does that. With a NAS you do it yourself, with your own equipment. With a private cloud, management lies with your organisation or with a provider who does it for you, in an environment that is only for you.
How do you choose?
Start from your question and from your technical knowledge and time, and then choose the form.
- Choose cloud storage if you value convenience, access from anywhere and little management.
- Choose a NAS if you want to keep a lot of data locally and are willing to manage it and make a copy off-site.
- Choose a private cloud if your organisation has requirements for control, compliance and scale.
- Combine forms if you want both fast local access and a copy in another location.
What role does backup play?
None of the three is a backup by itself. Synchronisation mirrors deletions, a NAS is in one location and a private cloud needs its own recovery agreements. So decide for each form how you keep a separate copy.
The three forms compared
| Characteristic | Cloud storage | NAS | Private cloud |
|---|---|---|---|
| Management | By the provider | By yourself | By your organisation or a managing party |
| Cost structure | Recurring subscription | Purchase, drives and electricity | Investment or fixed commitment plus management |
| Control over data | Limited, depends on the provider | Large | Large |
| Access on the go | Available as standard | Requires extra configuration and security | Depends on the design |
| Scalability | Quick to scale up | Limited by hardware | High, but with planning |
Who is this less suitable for?
- Anyone who has no time for management and updates had better not rely on a NAS alone.
- Small users rarely need a private cloud; cloud storage or a NAS is then usually enough.
Frequently asked questions
Can I combine a NAS and cloud storage?
Yes. Many people keep data locally on a NAS and make an encrypted copy in the cloud as an off-site backup.
Is a private cloud the same as a server of my own?
Not exactly. A private cloud is an environment that is only for you, but it can run at a provider or be located on your own premises.
What is the most secure?
That depends on configuration and management, not only on the form. Assess encryption, access management and recovery for each solution.
