NAS or external hard drive for backups?
An external drive is simple for one computer, a NAS makes backups for several devices possible; neither is a complete strategy.
An external hard drive is simple and suitable for one computer. A NAS makes automatic backups of several devices possible and stays reachable in your network. Both are usually in one place, so you also need a copy elsewhere.
Who is it for: Home users and small offices choosing how to store their backups locally.
What does an external drive do well?
You connect an external drive to your computer with a cable. That makes it easy to understand and quick to start using. Many operating systems have built-in backup functions that can write to such a drive.
The flip side is that the backup only works when the drive is connected. Anyone who forgets to connect the drive has no up-to-date backup. A drive that is permanently attached to the computer also shares the same risks, such as ransomware or a power surge.
What does a NAS add?
A NAS sits in your network and can collect backups from several devices automatically, even when you are not paying attention. Phones, laptops and a desktop can all write to the same place, with separate accounts per person.
A NAS also often offers version history and multiple drives with RAID. RAID helps when a drive fails, but is not a backup in itself. Check per model which backup software is included and which operating systems are supported.
Which choice fits which situation?
The choice depends on the number of devices, the amount of data and how much management you want to do.
- one computer and little management: external drive
- several devices or a household: NAS
- very little budget for management and little data: external drive or cloud backup
- need for automatic and regular backups without any action: NAS
What applies to both?
Both an external drive and a NAS are usually in the same place as your computer. In case of fire, burglary or water damage you lose both. So keep at least one copy in a different location, for example a second drive with family or an encrypted copy in the cloud.
Also test your backup. A backup that you have not yet restored is an assumption. Now and then pick a file and see whether you can recover it.
External drive and NAS compared for backups
| Criterion | External drive | NAS |
|---|---|---|
| Number of devices | Usually one at a time | Several devices at the same time via the network |
| Automatic | Only when the drive is connected | On a schedule, even without a cable |
| Failure protection | None, unless you use two drives | Possible with RAID when there are several drives |
| Management | Little | Updates, accounts and drive checks |
| Single-location risk | Yes | Yes, unless you make a copy elsewhere |
Who is it not ideal for?
- Anyone with one laptop and little time: an external drive is simpler than a NAS.
- Anyone who hopes RAID replaces a backup: a second copy in another place is still needed.
- Anyone who does not test the backup: choose the solution that you will actually use.
Frequently asked questions
How long does a hard drive last?
That differs greatly per drive and usage. Expect drives to wear out and plan for replacement instead of waiting until one fails.
Can I connect an external drive to a NAS?
That is often possible via a USB port. Check with the manufacturer whether your model supports this and for which tasks, such as an extra backup.
Is an SSD better than a regular drive for backups?
For archives and backups it is mainly about capacity and reliability. Both types can fail, so the same applies here: make a second copy.
How often should I make a backup?
That depends on how much work you can afford to lose. Many people choose daily or continuous, so that you lose at most a day of changes.
