Cloud Storage or an External Hard Drive: Which Suits You?
Both options keep your files, but they work differently and each has its own points to watch.
An external hard drive is a one-off, local solution that you control yourself. Cloud storage is online and can be reached from several devices. Which one suits you depends on what you store and how often you need to get at it. Many people combine the two.
What is the main difference?
You connect an external hard drive to your computer with a cable. Your files are then physically at your home or office. Cloud storage keeps your files on a provider’s servers, which you reach over the internet.
That difference determines almost everything: where you can get at your files, who looks after it and which risks apply. A drive can be dropped or lost, whereas with cloud storage your account and internet connection play a role.
You could compare it to a bookcase at home versus a library. With the bookcase you have everything in your own hands and can get to it without a membership. In the library you do not have to maintain anything yourself and can visit from several places, but you depend on the organisation’s opening hours and rules.
When is an external hard drive useful?
An external drive is practical if you want to keep large amounts of data locally, such as video footage or an old photo archive. Transferring files is usually fast, because there is no internet connection in between.
You also have full control yourself: no account or subscription is involved. If you want your files to stay offline on purpose, a separate drive is a logical choice.
Do bear in mind that drives wear out and can fail. Fire, theft or water damage at your home can also hit the drive and your computer at the same time. A drive is therefore not automatically a safe place for the only copy of a file.
A practical point is that the connection and the file system of drives can differ. A drive that works well with a Windows computer may need a different format for a Mac. So check beforehand what your devices support.
When is cloud storage useful?
Cloud storage is practical if you want to reach the same files from several devices, such as your phone, laptop and tablet. Sharing is also often easier: you send a link instead of a file.
Your files are also not in the same place as your computer. If it breaks or is stolen, your files may still be kept elsewhere. That does depend on how you use the service, see also sync or backup.
Points to watch are your internet connection, the amount of space in your plan and the question of who holds the keys to your data. You can find more on the latter in the guide is cloud storage safe?
With cloud storage, speed depends on your connection. Uploading large amounts of data often takes longer than downloading. The first transfer of a large photo collection can therefore take days, whereas afterwards only new files need to be added.
Cloud storage and an external drive side by side
| Topic | External hard drive | Cloud storage |
|---|---|---|
| Access | Only where the drive is | Via the internet, on several devices |
| Maintenance | By you | By the provider |
| Sharing | Copy the file or hand it over | Often via a link |
| Risks | Failure, loss, theft | Account security, reliance on the internet |
| Costs | One-off purchase | Often an ongoing subscription |
These are general differences. Check the specifications and terms for each product.
Can you combine them?
Yes, and many people do. A well-known rule of thumb is the 3-2-1 backup rule: keep several copies, on different types of storage, with one of them in a different location. An external drive at home and a copy in the cloud fit that well.
An example from daily life: your family photos are on your laptop, a copy is on an external drive in the cupboard and a third copy is with a cloud provider. If one of the three is lost, your photos are not gone yet.
Would you like more explanation about choosing between online and local? Then also read cloud or local storage.
Such a combination does not have to be complicated. You can use the cloud for what you need every day and the drive for an archive that you consult less often.
What do you look at when choosing?
First think about what you are storing. If it is documents that you want to be able to open anywhere, cloud storage often works well. If it is a large collection of videos that you only watch at home, a drive or NAS may feel more logical.
- Amount of data: how much space do you need, now and in a few years?
- Access: do you want to reach it on the go, or mainly at home?
- Privacy: do you want to manage your files yourself, or do you trust a provider?
- Maintenance: do you like having someone else look after it, or would you rather do it yourself?
There is no answer that is right for everyone. Anyone who knows what they are storing and why usually arrives at a suitable choice quickly. After that, check the specifications and terms of the product you are considering. Would you like to know how cloud storage works technically? Then read how does cloud storage actually work.
Frequently asked questions
Is an external hard drive safer than cloud storage?
That depends on what you mean by safe. A drive is offline as long as you keep it disconnected and is under your own control, but it can fail or get lost. Cloud storage is managed by a provider, but calls for good account security.
Do I need both?
Not everyone does, but a combination can reduce the risk of loss. For important files, many people choose a local copy and a copy online.
How long does an external hard drive last?
That differs per type and use. Drives can fail over time, so it is wise not to rely on a single copy.
Further reading
Last updated on
