What Is RAID and Which Type Suits Your NAS?
RAID combines several drives into one storage space; these are the common levels and what they mean in practice.
RAID combines several drives into one storage space, so that you can get more speed, more capacity or protection against drive failure. Which level suits depends on the number of drives and what you find important. RAID is not a backup: it does not protect against deletion, ransomware or fire.
What is RAID and why use it in a NAS?
RAID stands for redundant array of independent disks. In a NAS it is used to make drives work together. You then see a single volume, while in the background the data is spread or copied across several drives.
Why do people do this? Drives fail over time. Without RAID, the data on that drive is gone. With certain RAID levels, the NAS keeps running if one drive fails, and you can replace it while the rest remains available.
The common RAID levels at a glance
Below is a simple overview. The exact way it works can differ slightly per manufacturer and software.
| Level | Minimum number of drives | What does it do? |
|---|---|---|
| RAID 0 | 2 | Spreads data across drives for speed and full capacity, but without protection. |
| RAID 1 | 2 | Mirrors the data: each drive holds the same data. |
| RAID 5 | 3 | Spreads data and parity; one drive may fail. |
| RAID 6 | 4 | Like RAID 5, but two drives may fail. |
| RAID 10 | 4 | A combination of mirroring and striping, with plenty of speed and protection. |
Some manufacturers offer their own variants that give more flexibility when combining drives of different sizes. Check your brand’s documentation for the details.
What happens when a drive fails?
With RAID 1, 5, 6 and 10, the NAS can keep working if one drive fails. You usually get a notification, fit a new drive and the system rebuilds the data. That rebuild can take hours to days, depending on the size of the drives and how busy the NAS is.
During that rebuild the system is more vulnerable, because the remaining drives are heavily loaded. That is why some people choose a level that can cope with more than one failed drive, especially with larger drives.
RAID is not a backup
This is the most important point. RAID protects against a faulty drive, but not against:
- Files deleted or overwritten by accident.
- Ransomware or other malicious software.
- Fire, theft or water damage.
- A faulty controller or errors in the software.
A real backup is a separate copy on another device or in another location. Read more in the 3-2-1 backup rule and in NAS backup strategy. Snapshots help with deleted files, but stay on the same NAS, see NAS snapshots explained.
Which RAID level suits your situation?
There is no universal answer, but here are a few guidelines:
- Two drives: RAID 1 is a common choice for protection against failure.
- Three or four drives: RAID 5 gives a good balance between space and protection, although many people take the rebuild time into account.
- Four or more drives: RAID 6 or RAID 10 can be attractive if you want extra safety or speed.
The number of available bays therefore determines your options, see how many drive bays does a NAS need. Also check which drives your NAS supports in which drives for a NAS.
A simple example from daily life
Say you have two drives in a mirror. You keep the photos from the past few years on it. One day one drive starts making strange noises and fails. Because the second drive holds a complete copy, your photos remain available. You buy a replacement drive, fit it and the NAS rebuilds the copy.
If in that same week you accidentally delete a whole folder of holiday photos, that folder is gone from both drives, because the mirror dutifully copies the deletion too. This shows why RAID and backup are two different things.
That is why, when choosing a RAID level, it is wise to look not only at capacity or speed, but also at how quickly you can replace a failed drive. Do not leave a spare drive or replacement waiting too long. Also look at your NAS’s manual, because the procedure for a faulty drive differs per system.
Finally, a word about maintenance. RAID gives you time to react to a failed drive, but only if you notice it. Switch on notifications, so that you get an email or push message if a drive gives warnings. Many NAS systems can also check the drives periodically for errors, known as a scrub or integrity check.
Also schedule a check of your backup every so often. A RAID set-up that has been in a degraded state for months without anyone noticing offers little protection. Small habits make the difference here.
Frequently asked questions
Is RAID 5 safe enough?
RAID 5 protects against the failure of one drive. With large drives a rebuild can take a long time, and during that period there is no extra protection. Consider a level with more tolerance and in any case arrange a separate backup.
Can I change RAID later?
That depends on the NAS system. Some systems can convert certain levels, others require starting again. Check this in the manual before you begin.
Do all NAS systems have RAID?
No. Models with a single drive bay cannot use RAID, and some systems have their own storage methods. Check the specifications.
Further reading
Last updated on
