Which Drives for a NAS? What to Look For When Choosing
NAS drives are made for continuous use; these are the points to look at when choosing.
For a NAS you usually choose drives that are suitable for continuous use in a multi-drive system. Look at the NAS manufacturer’s support list, the recording type (CMR or SMR), the capacity and the noise. Check the official specifications of both the NAS and the drive.
Why an ordinary drive is not necessarily suitable
A NAS often runs around the clock and contains several drives side by side. That asks something different of a drive than a PC that runs for a few hours a day.
Drives for NAS use are therefore designed for long-term use, for the vibration of drives spinning next to each other and for error handling in a RAID set-up. Ordinary desktop drives can work in a NAS, but manufacturers often recommend drives made specifically for this use. Read your NAS brand’s recommendations.
CMR or SMR: what does it mean?
Hard drives write data in different ways. With CMR (conventional magnetic recording), tracks lie side by side. With SMR (shingled magnetic recording), they overlap, like roof tiles, to fit more data on the same surface.
SMR can become slower during prolonged writing, for example while rebuilding a RAID set-up. NAS and drive manufacturers often publish information on which type a model uses. Check this on the official product page, especially if you want to use RAID.
Capacity, speed and noise
Larger drives offer more space per bay, but also take longer to rebuild. A few considerations:
- Capacity: work out what you need with a buffer for growth, see how much storage space do I need.
- Rotational speed: some drives spin faster than others. That can affect performance, but also noise and heat.
- Noise: is the NAS in the living room or in a cupboard? That determines how important noise is to you.
- Power consumption: more drives and faster spinning usually mean more energy.
Compatibility with your NAS
Many manufacturers publish a list of drives they have tested or support. A drive that is not on the list can often work technically, but sometimes the NAS shows a warning or features such as health notifications are missing. So check the list for your model before you buy drives.
Mixing drives? Preferably use drives with the same capacity and similar specifications in one RAID group. Different brands or series can sometimes be used together, but this differs per system. You can find how RAID works in RAID explained for NAS users.
Can you use SSDs in a NAS?
Yes, many NAS systems with 2.5-inch or 3.5-inch bays also accept SSDs. They are quiet and fast, but usually offer less capacity per bay than hard drives. They are often used for fast storage of smaller files or for virtual machines.
Some NAS systems also have M.2 slots for fast SSDs, for example as cache. You can read how that works in M.2 slots in a NAS explained.
Practical tips for fitting and testing
If possible, do not buy all the drives from the same production batch, because a manufacturing fault could then hit several drives at once. When you first put new drives into use, test them with the NAS’s utilities, such as a drive scan.
Keep an eye on health through the system’s notifications and arrange a separate backup. You can find an overview of models on the NAS page.
An example: you buy four drives for a new NAS and fit them all at once. After fitting, check in the management screen that all drives are recognised and that their health looks good. Note down the model numbers and purchase dates, for example in a simple overview. That helps if a drive has to be replaced in a few years’ time and you want to know which type was in there.
Also take into account the warranty terms and the expected lifespan of the drive, as stated on the official product page. It is better to plan replacement in good time than when a drive is already giving warnings.
Finally: do not buy drives on capacity alone. Look at the recommended annual workload that manufacturers sometimes state, the warranty period and the ability to have the drive checked through the NAS software. Someone using a NAS at home usually has a lower workload than a small office, but choosing a drive for continuous use remains logical because the NAS is often on.
Want to know how to combine drives in a safe set-up? Then read on in RAID explained for NAS users.
What is on the datasheet of a NAS drive, and what should you look for?
Look up the datasheet of the exact model on the manufacturer’s site. The datasheets of Western Digital and Seagate, among others, contain these rows, among others:
- Recording technology: CMR or SMR. Western Digital states that WD Red drives exist in both versions and refers to the datasheet.
- Workload rate: the annual workload the drive is designed for.
- MTBF and warranty: for comparing models.
- Bays supported: Seagate lists the number of drive bays a series is intended for.
- Acoustics and power: relevant if the NAS sits in the living room.
Then check with the NAS manufacturer whether the model is supported. Western Digital advises this even if your model is not on the list.
Frequently asked questions
Can I use an ordinary hard drive in a NAS?
Technically that is often possible, but manufacturers usually recommend drives made for NAS use. Look at your NAS’s support list.
What is the difference between CMR and SMR?
CMR writes tracks side by side, SMR lets tracks overlap. SMR can become slower during prolonged writing, which can play a part in a RAID rebuild.
Do all the drives in my NAS have to be the same size?
Not necessarily, but with many RAID types the smallest drive determines the usable space. Some systems handle different sizes more flexibly.
Further reading
Last updated on
